[CrashList] Nader Rally in San Antonio

Amiri Baraka ab11 at erols.net
Wed Nov 8 17:26:04 MST 2000


-----Original Message-----
From:	JFortun845 at aol.com [SMTP:JFortun845 at aol.com]
Sent:	Sunday, October 22, 2000 9:50 AM
To:	crashlist at lists.wwpublish.com
Subject:	Re: [CrashList] Nader Rally in San Antonio


Although you are raising valid criticisms here, I think you are being 
somewhat unfair and one-sided (undialectical) about the Green party and Green 

What you fail to recognize is that, although Ralph Nader may indeed have 
limitations in his populist presentation, many in the Green Party recognize 
these limitations and in fact have an anti-capitalist world view of their own 
and are bringing this world view to the thousands of young people that the 
Nader campaign has introduced to independent political action.

The principle aspect of the Nader campaign, in my view, is that it targets 
the system of monopoly capitalism; for instance, when Nader talks about the 
political system being dominated "by one corporate party with two heads, 
sometimes wearing different makeup." Or when he takes on "corporate welfare" 
or denounces the "plutocracy." He may be somewhat limited in his solutions 
but this is meant to be more than just an educational campaign, such as those 
being run by Workers World, the Socialists or the SWP, which have been 
running educational campaigns for decades to no appreciable avail. In 
contrast, the Nader campaign is a serious effort to establish an 
anti-corporate progressive third party on the American scene. It is an 
attempt to unite the many to defeat the few, as a famous Chinese philosopher 
once put it. It is a historic effort and the Left should not miss the boat, 
or the opportunity to choose the course, by standing on the sidelines.

Certainly there are limitations but they are not as bad as you make them out 
to be. Sure, some in the Greens uphold the Vincente Fox election in Mexico as 
an advance but this is not the only view held in the Green movement. And he 
is not a Green, as your posting seems to imply, although I am given to 
understand that their are Greens in his new government. As far as being 
"Social Democrats without the Labor movement," many Greens recognize the 
central role of labor in building this movement. Many mainstream Greens talk 
of a "Blue-Green alliance" and some talk of a Green Labor Caucus. BTW, the UE 
has endorsed Nader, as has the California Nurses Association and many in the 

Many have struggled with Nader to speak out more forcefully against racism 
and on social justice issues and he has responded to the pressure. Check out 
the platform. It has positions for effective and independent civilian review 
of police brutality complaints and against the criminalization of our youth 
and against the privatization of the prison system; it calls for reparations 
for descendants of the African-American slaves and calls for outlawing the 
flying of the Confederate battle flag over state buildings.

Crashlist resources: http://website.lineone.net/~resource_base
To change your options or unsubscribe go to:
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/ms-tnef
Size: 40194 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://greenhouse.economics.utah.edu/pipermail/a-list/attachments/20001108/2ed928a1/attachment.bin>

More information about the A-List mailing list